The Man History Blamed
John Wilkes Booth
Actor. Confederate sympathizer. Architect of the Lincoln assassination conspiracy. But was he the one who pulled the trigger?
Early Life and Rise to Fame
John Wilkes Booth was born on May 10, 1838, at Tudor Hall farm in Bel Air, Maryland, the ninth of ten children of the celebrated English-born actor Junius Brutus Booth. The Booth family was theatrical royalty in mid-19th century America — his father was one of the most acclaimed Shakespearean actors of his era, and his brothers Edwin and Junius Jr. were also prominent on the stage. John Wilkes inherited the family gift. By his mid-twenties he was one of the most popular and highest-paid actors in the United States, known for his dark good looks, athletic stage presence, and electrifying performances in roles like Richard III, Hamlet, and Romeo.
Confederate Sympathizer in a Divided Nation
Despite his Northern birth and career, Booth was a passionate Confederate sympathizer. He had witnessed the hanging of abolitionist John Brown in 1859 — an event that radicalized him. As the Civil War ground on and Confederate fortunes declined, Booth grew increasingly obsessed with the idea of striking a decisive blow for the South. He began recruiting a network of conspirators in 1864, initially planning to kidnap President Lincoln and hold him hostage in exchange for the release of Confederate prisoners of war. The plan was never executed. When General Robert E. Lee surrendered at Appomattox on April 9, 1865, Booth's kidnapping scheme collapsed — and he pivoted to something far more drastic.
The Night of April 14, 1865 — What the Official Account Says
On the evening of April 14, 1865, President Abraham Lincoln attended a performance of 'Our American Cousin' at Ford's Theatre in Washington D.C. Booth, who was well known at the theatre and moved freely through it, had learned that Lincoln would be attending. He coordinated simultaneous attacks: he would handle Lincoln personally, while co-conspirator Lewis Powell attacked Secretary of State William Seward at his home, and George Atzerodt was assigned to kill Vice President Andrew Johnson. The official account holds that Booth entered Lincoln's presidential box at approximately 10:15 p.m., fired a single-shot .44 caliber Philadelphia Deringer into the back of Lincoln's head, then leapt to the stage — catching his spur on the bunting and breaking his left fibula — and shouted 'Sic semper tyrannis!' before escaping on horseback through the back of the theatre.
The Deringer: One Shot, One Chance
The weapon attributed to Booth was a Philadelphia Deringer — a small, single-shot percussion cap pistol with a 2.5-inch barrel. It was a close-range weapon by design, accurate only within a few feet. The official account places Booth directly behind Lincoln in the presidential box, pressing the muzzle close to the back of Lincoln's head before firing. The bullet entered behind Lincoln's left ear and lodged behind his right eye. Lincoln never regained consciousness and died the following morning at 7:22 a.m. at the Petersen House across the street from Ford's Theatre. The Deringer itself was recovered at the scene and is now on display at Ford's Theatre National Historic Site.
What Paul Mellen's Research Challenges
Paul Mellen does not dispute that John Wilkes Booth was present at Ford's Theatre on the night of April 14, 1865, or that he was the mastermind of the assassination conspiracy. What Mellen's research challenges is the assumption that Booth fired the fatal shot. His evidence — drawn from primary source documents at the National Archives, Canadian government records, and British historical files — points to a second man in Lincoln's presidential box: John Surratt, a Confederate spy and Union double agent who Mellen identifies as the actual gunman. In Mellen's account, Booth served as the visible, theatrical face of the plot — the decoy whose dramatic leap to the stage drew every eye in the theatre — while Surratt carried out the killing itself.
Booth's Escape Route: Twelve Days as a Fugitive
After the assassination, Booth fled south on horseback with co-conspirator David Herold. He stopped at the home of Dr. Samuel Mudd in Maryland, who set his broken leg — a decision that would cost Mudd a life sentence. Booth and Herold then crossed into Virginia, hiding in swamps and relying on Confederate sympathizers along a route that took them through Port Tobacco, across the Potomac River, and into the Virginia countryside. For twelve days, the largest manhunt in American history pursued them. On April 26, 1865, Union cavalry surrounded the Garrett farm near Port Royal, Virginia. Herold surrendered. The man believed to be Booth was shot by Sergeant Boston Corbett after refusing to come out of the burning tobacco barn.
The Body at Garrett's Farm: Questions That Won't Die
The identification of the body at Garrett's farm has been disputed by historians for over 150 years. The man was shot in the neck in a darkened barn, identified by a handful of witnesses in the middle of the night, and buried in secret under the floor of a Washington arsenal — not exactly the conditions for a rigorous identification. Paul Mellen's research examines these inconsistencies in detail. The rushed conclusion of the manhunt, he argues, served the interests of powerful figures who wanted the case closed before the full truth about the conspiracy — and who was really behind it — could emerge. Whether the man killed at Garrett's farm was truly John Wilkes Booth remains one of the most debated questions in Lincoln assassination history.
Legacy and the Unanswered Question
John Wilkes Booth has been fixed in American memory as the man who killed Abraham Lincoln — the most consequential political assassination in United States history. His name is synonymous with treachery and fanaticism. But Paul Mellen's research asks a question that the official history has never fully answered: if Booth was the shooter, why do the primary source documents from three countries point to someone else? The answer, Mellen argues, lies in a deliberate cover-up orchestrated in the days and weeks after the assassination — one designed to protect powerful interests and close the case before the full truth could emerge.
Booth planned the conspiracy. But did he pull the trigger? The evidence says no.
Read the Full EvidenceFrequently Asked Questions
The Full Story Is in the Book
Paul Mellen's fully illustrated investigation traces the complete evidence trail — from Ford's Theatre to the pyramids of Egypt. If you've ever questioned the official account of Lincoln's assassination, this is the book that answers the question history left open.
Order the Book NowWho Really Shot Abraham Lincoln?
If Booth didn't fire the fatal shot, who did? Paul Mellen's fully illustrated book reveals the evidence — as featured on Fox Nation.
ISBN 978-0-578-93580-5 · Available on eBay